Background:
I work for the federal government and was fortunate enough to have most of the study material, eight days of classroom instruction, and my voucher provided at no cost to myself. This review will be most beneficial to people in a similar situation to myself.
I have a Masters in IT, have been working in security since about 2009. Currently I focus most of my work on patch management and system compliance. I earned Security+ a few years ago and began the 'passive' study phase of my CISSP effort in September 2015 by studying for and earning the Certified Ethical Hacker certification.
I began 'actively' studying for the CISSP three weeks before my exam and passed on February 11th, taking 1hr45 minutes to complete the exam.
Written Study Material:
CISSP (ISC)2 Certified Information Systems Security Professional Official Study Guide 7th Edition (ISBN 978-1119042716)
Eleventh Hour CISSP: Study Guide 2nd Edition (ISBN 978-012417142

CISSP Exam Cram 3rd Edition (ISBN 978-0789749574)
CISSP All-in-One Exam Guide, 6th Edition (ISBN 978-0071781749)
CISSP Study Guide 3rd Edition (ISBN 978-0128024379)
Official (ISC)2 Guide to the CISSP CBK 4th Edition (ISBN 978-1482262759)
Video Material:
Kelly Handerhan at Cybrary -
https://www.cybrary.it/course/cissp/Test Engines:
Sybex/Wiley (Sybex 7th Edition) -
https://sybextestbanks.wiley.com/
Total Tester (A-I-O 6th Edition) -
Total Seminars - Best selling books plus practice exams for A+, Network+, and IC3 certification
Cram Master Online -
http://crammasteronline.com/Misc: https://www.safaribooksonline.com/https://www.reddit.com/r/cisspMy process:
I began five months before my exam by sitting for the C|EH exam. Some CISSPs in my organization felt that I wouldn't gain very much from the experience but I disagree. Security Assessment and Testing, Security Operations, and Security Engineering were all domains that have significant overlap with the C|EH curriculum. Specifically I was well prepared for cryptology, the OSI model, how IPSec works, vulnerabilites, and tools/methods for vulnerability testing because of the C|EH work.
For the next four months I did my normal routine. I listened to my security podcasts (Security Now! w/Steven Gibson) and continued to investigate general industry knowledge through work and security news sites. Nothing particularly intensive or focused.
Three weeks before the exam, one week before my classroom instruction started, I read the Conrad 11th Hour book over the course of two nights. It's short and only took about 2 hours total. It's very shallow as it's essentially an expanded glossary with no filler or deep details. It did serve as a nice, targeted introduction to the testable material.
After laying the foundation with the 11th Hour book I started reading the full Sybex 7th book. I tried to keep up with a chapter or two per night and ended up finishing it over the course of two weeks. I gave it one honest read through and it served as the backbone of my studies, I can't stress how valuable the Sybex 7th was to my studies.
After I finished about 25% of the Sybex 7th I began watching the Cybrary videos. These are exceptional, and free. Kelly covers the material in a way that really helps you not just retain it, but understand it so you can apply it to the exam questions. I'd put this series of videos ahead of ITPro.TV, CBT Nuggets, and FedVTE if I were forced to choose. The total series is just under 16 hours and I watched them over the course of about 7 days. Close to the test I went back and rewatched a few key segments that I still felt weak in.
Two weeks to go to the exam and I was 75% done with Sybex 7th. I finished it about seven days before the exam and did not return to it. Having completed Sybex 7th and Cybrary I began using test engines to gauge what my weaknesses were. The class I went to provided the Cram Master account and I started doing those questions first. They were by far the easiest but were useful in that the engine tracked my progress to show which domains I was the best and worst in. I used this information to direct the course of my studies.
The Saturday before my exam I downloaded the Total Tester test engine and took a full 250 question simulated exam. I was discouraged to see that I tested below 70% in three domains, but I knew where I had to focus. In my case I needed to emphasise more on BCP/DRP, Comm/Network Security, and Physical Security (fire safety). I continued to use the Total Tester engine for the next three days, taking short 25 question exams. During this time I review the Exam Cram 3rd in the areas I need help, and also take a very quick look at the All-In-One 6th to get in in-depth explanation of BCP. The Harris book is too detailed and was not helpful to me.
Three days before the exam I switch to the Sybex 7th test engine and take short 25 question exams a few times a day. I never scored higher than 90% on any one exam. This engine has questions that are the closest to the actual exam in tone and content. I reread the 11th Hour book over two nights.
One day before the exam I study for a few hours early and then mentally check out. I take my wife to dinner, have two beers, spend the evening playing Rocket League and go to bed early.
Test day, it's -18F in Wisconsin on the way to the test center. Awesome. Doesn't matter, once the test starts you're not focused on anything but the questions anyway. Of the 250 questions I completed, absolutely none of them were in any of the test engines I used. None. People say this all the time, but do know that if you're banking on rote familiarization you're not going to get it here. You'd think at least a few would accidently line up, but, nope. Learn the material, do not waste time on memorizing questions. You can take breaks so I gave myself limits and took a break at 100 and 180 questions. Do this, even if you think you don't have to. I felt so much better once I got back into my chair after stretching my legs and visiting the restroom. Trust me, you'll feel better. I finished in 1hr 45min, including the breaks. I subscribe to the philosophy that you either know the answer or you don't, so I did not flag any questions and did not go back and review anything. Of the six people taking the exam in my group, all but one passed.
Test tips:
-If you see a concept on the exam that you didn't cover in your studies, don't sweat it, it's probably a non-graded pilot question. There were a few that I knew for sure were not mentioned anywhere in my studies.
-Don't worry about complex simulations or anything, it is mostly multiple choice and some matching.
-The safety of people is most important. People are also your weakest link, mostly because of social engineering.
-Understanding Single Sign-On (SSO) technologies, well established and emerging, is very important.
-It really is a management exam, don't spend an overly abundent amount of time on technical details. Personally I wish I had spent less time on Comm/Network and more time on Software Development.
-Use Test Engines to see where you stand so you know which domains to focus on. Don't just take endless questions and think you're helping yourself. I recommend not even starting with test engines until 10 days before sitting for the exam.
-You're time is best spent reading, reading, reading as many different sources as you can. It's all based on the same CBK but the different deliveries will facilitate your understanding of the material.
Material Review:
CISSP (ISC)2 Certified Information Systems Security Professional Official Study Guide 7th Edition (ISBN 978-1119042716)
-The backbone of my study tools. Highly recommend.
Eleventh Hour CISSP: Study Guide 2nd Edition (ISBN 978-012417142

-Excellent foundation/review text. I read it twice.
CISSP Exam Cram 3rd Edition (ISBN 978-0789749574)
-Used this text to fill in some gaps near the end. Lots of erratta and typos. .mobi/ePub format available on Safari Books.
CISSP All-in-One Exam Guide, 6th Edition (ISBN 978-0071781749)
-Barely used this, I wish I hadn't. If I were going to setup a BCP/DRP program, I'd use this text. Total overkill for this exam.
CISSP Study Guide 3rd Edition (ISBN 978-0128024379)
-Did not use, was the classroom text for the course I attended.
Official (ISC)2 Guide to the CISSP CBK 4th Edition (ISBN 978-1482262759)
-Did not use, dry.
Kelly Handerhan at Cybrary -
https://www.cybrary.it/course/cissp/
-Amazing, can't recommend them enough. It was free but I'm going to donate to them as a thank you. All of the video lectures are also available as audio mp3 tracks. Their mobile app allows you to take the videos with you everywhere, as well.
Test Engine Review:
Sybex/Wiley (Sybex 7th Edition) -
https://sybextestbanks.wiley.com/
-Closest to the actual exam, I saved it for last. Web based. Also has 600 flash cards that I went through once early but never looked at again.
Total Tester (A-I-O 6th Edition) -
Total Seminars - Best selling books plus practice exams for A+, Network+, and IC3 certification
-Questions are more technical than the actual test, great for challenging yourself.
Cram Master Online -
http://crammasteronline.com/
-Access provided by my employer, questions are soft. Their platform works really great on mobile browsers. I would lay in bed at night and try questions until I fell asleep.
Misc Items:https://www.safaribooksonline.com/
-Free for people with .mil e-mails. Has a 10-day Trial if you want to check it out otherwise. Almost all of these materials are available on there, some in Kindle/ePub format.
I'm happy to answer any questions about any of this, so long as it's not about specific items on the test. Fire away.
On to endorsement. I already have an Endorser ready to review my resume, I just don't fully understand the "two domains in five years" requirement. Is that two domains within five years, or two domains with five years of experience each? I'm going to call ISC2 next week to get a definitive answer. I know cyberguypr advises you can mix and match to get to five but I want to be sure (see it in writing or talk to ISC2) before I give my paperwork to my endorser.
I'll post the progress of my endorsement process as I reach those milestones.
TL;DR version:
Read 11th Hour
Read Sybex 7th
Watch Cybrary
Use Test Engines to see where you're weak
Read more material on weak domains
Read 11th Hour