Cisco Core Switches

I agree with pitviper. If you went layer 3 with 10/100 you could probably fall into the price range you want. Anything above that and you are pushing it. You might be able to get two or 4 gig interfaces in it for trunking. I'd look at 3750's.

While they are good switches, they are not really core worthy unless its a pretty small network. Cisco chassis based switches (4500 and 6500) are their core designed switches. And those cost big money.

Edit: Mike, do you have anything to say about them and their company customer service? Or anything in general?

NightShade03

I used 3750's at my last job for our core network. I had a pair of them with 2 GBic for fiber trunking...which def put me over the 3k mark...but maybe used you might be able to pull this off. We also had a small network...maybe 100 network devices at most.

I actually wouldn't go Cisco for that spot with that kind of budget. Since this sounds like a smaller network, I'd use 4500's if I could get away with it, that way there's some scalability in the core.

If your only choice is to go fixed configuration switches, I'd look into acquiring a couple Force10 S50's

keenon

I would look at HP 5300 series on the core switch if you plan on used. the lifetime warranty enough is reason and the cli isn't too far off from cisco.

mikearama

chmorin wrote: »

Mike, do you have anything to say about them and their company customer service? Or anything in general?

They're fine. Service was good. I've used them several times in my last gig to set up remote offices... switches and pixes.

They are not the cheapest around... I wouldn't use them to build a home network.

I've dealt with NHR as a vendor before as well, and they've always been solid. I've never received bad or counterfeit gear from them.

thenjduke

I am looking at the Cisco 4948. The price is about 7k with smarnet.

thenjduke wrote: »

I am looking at the Cisco 4948. The price is about 7k with smarnet.

A bit above your 3k budget

I wish we could pull that XD

thenjduke

Yes but that is okay. I got the CEO to approve them. They know the core switch network needs to be done. It is a start to move from Dell Switches to Cisco world here. I need all the practice I can get for my CCNP Studies

thenjduke wrote: »

Yes but that is okay. I got the CEO to approve them. They know the core switch network needs to be done. It is a start to move from Dell Switches to Cisco world here. I need all the practice I can get for my CCNP Studies

Well most people around here will agree with yah, it is a good investment for sure

DPG

Cisco 6509 with redundant SUP2's, redundant power, and a few gigabit fiber line cards is easily under $3k.

deth1k

DPG wrote: »

Cisco 6509 with redundant SUP2's, redundant power, and a few gigabit fiber line cards is easily under $3k.

yea you wish :P

bmauro

Well if we are budgeting in "fantasy land

" you might as well look at what we have in our core.....easily under your 3K budget :P

Cisco Nexus 7000 10-Slot Switch - Cisco Systems - loaded up with 10G line cards...

And you don't need redundant SUPs when you have two of em.....

Why buy one when you can get two for twice the price???

DPG wrote: »

Cisco 6509 with redundant SUP2's, redundant power, and a few gigabit fiber line cards is easily under $3k.

I assume you're joking :P If not then I want to talk to your Cisco account manager for a similar discount.

thenjduke wrote: »

I do not need Fiber and it does need layer 3 capabilities. I need at least 24 or 48 ports on both switches.

How big is this network you're designing?

3K for a core switch with 48 ports is a tad ambitious. You going to be using GigE or 10G? 10G would completely blow your budget on a single line card so I guess not...

CCNAwannabe

I'm a Cisco Select Certified Partner. If you need prices on NEW equipment then let me know. I can usually come close to the refurb guys, because it's a small business and I have no overhead. You can check my site out at RedBug Computer Services LLC (OK so I marketed a little bit)

Robbie

DPG

tiersten wrote: »

I assume you're joking :P If not then I want to talk to your Cisco account manager for a similar discount.

Uhhhh....

Cisco 6509 chassis - $150

2x Cisco 1800W PSU $150

2x Cisco SUP2 - $150

Your choice of line cards from $75 - $150 each.

DPG wrote: »

Uhhhh....

Cisco 6509 chassis - $150

2x Cisco 1800W PSU $150

2x Cisco SUP2 - $150

Your choice of line cards from $75 - $150 each.

Ah okay. I didn't notice the Sup II part in your list earlier. You're quoting second hand prices for ancient gear. A Sup II is CatOS as well. You'd want a Sup II+MSFC or newer if you want L3 support and you'll need to pay to relicense IOS. Considering the price of your line cards, I assume they're all classic bus cards as well and won't do CEF or dCEF :P

If somebody proposed making a brand new network core with a 6509 (non E) and two ancient Sup IIs then I'd be worried.

tiersten wrote: »

If somebody proposed making a brand new network core with a 6509 (non E) and two ancient Sup IIs then I'd be worried.

Agreed, not really core worthy.

DPG

chmorin wrote: »

Agreed, not really core worthy.

Why not? They are perfectly capable and there are plenty still in production today.

DPG wrote: »

Why not? They are perfectly capable and there are plenty still in production today.

Perfectly capable of what? What hardware exactly are you listing anyway above? You've just got some random prices without saying what model it is.

Do the Sups have a MSFC? How about a SFM? Are the line cards classic bus or fabric? Port ASIC contention in the line cards? How much memory is in the Sups? Do you trust your network core to a bunch of secondhand gear? Did you factor in relicensing IOS? Can you even get a new SMARTnet contract on that old gear?

As for why I wouldn't use an old 6509 + 2xSups + random line cards is that there isn't much ability for expansion in the future. We've not even sure what thenjduke's requirements are.

networker050184

tiersten wrote: »

Perfectly capable of what? What hardware exactly are you listing anyway above? You've just got some random prices without saying what model it is.

Do the Sups have a MSFC? How about a SFM? Are the line cards classic bus or fabric? Port ASIC contention in the line cards? How much memory is in the Sups? Do you trust your network core to a bunch of secondhand gear? Did you factor in relicensing IOS? Can you even get a new SMARTnet contract on that old gear?

As for why I wouldn't use an old 6509 + 2xSups + random line cards is that there isn't much ability for expansion in the future. We've not even sure what thenjduke's requirements are.

+1 to this. Why buy gear already end of life? This isn't a lab we are talking about here. And who the hell wants CatOS anyway?

to play devil's advocate - I'd take that over what he's running in his core right now.

Otherwise, I'm a bit of a snob. If I have to use a 6500, it better have at least a sup720-3bxl

networker050184

Forsaken_GA wrote: »

to play devil's advocate - I'd take that over what he's running in his core right now.

Otherwise, I'm a bit of a snob. If I have to use a 6500, it better have at least a sup720-3bxl

I'd much rather recent supported Dell switches (not sure if thats what the OP has) than some outdated unsupported Cisco gear. If you are relieng on this for your network core you are going to want vendor support contracts for replacement and technical assistance. Do you really want to get woken up at 3A.M. for a hardware/software failure and not have vendor support? I know I wouldn't for damn sure.