Anyone experience with ClearOS ? Horrible throughput :(
jibbajabba
Member Posts: 4,317 ■■■■■■■■□□
in Off-Topic
At the moment I am running ClearOS in a virtual machine.
Here you can see the throughput using my external firewall as gateway (SonicWall)
Here using ClearOS as gateway
With an estimate of over 3 days for a 2.2GB file.
As you can see it is not just a little bit bad .. but pretty much unusable.
I am not using any filter etc. so I am a bit puzzeled as I hoped I can replace the (VERY old) Sonic ....
Edit: I just saw it picked up for a moment, but then crashed down to almost 0
It hasn't picked up since so I hope someone has seen this before ...........
I also now changed the NICs of the virtual machines with ClearOS to VMXNET3 with the same results.
Just as a sidenote .. the client and ClearOS are both installed onto the same physical ESX server (4.1u1) and both are connected to the same virtual switch. The virtual swtich is connected to an GbE uplink which is directly connected to a Cisco 3750G with unmetered connected (I am working in a hosting company myself). So all I am doing to test this is basically changing the virtual network card mapping from the virtual switch of the Sonic to the Clear OS router and vice versa and you immediately see the performance drop.
Here you can see the throughput using my external firewall as gateway (SonicWall)
0% [................................... ] 10,861,432 2.41M/s eta 20m 6s
Here using ClearOS as gateway
0% [................................... ] 4,021 2.53K/s
With an estimate of over 3 days for a 2.2GB file.
As you can see it is not just a little bit bad .. but pretty much unusable.
I am not using any filter etc. so I am a bit puzzeled as I hoped I can replace the (VERY old) Sonic ....
Edit: I just saw it picked up for a moment, but then crashed down to almost 0
It hasn't picked up since so I hope someone has seen this before ...........
I also now changed the NICs of the virtual machines with ClearOS to VMXNET3 with the same results.
Just as a sidenote .. the client and ClearOS are both installed onto the same physical ESX server (4.1u1) and both are connected to the same virtual switch. The virtual swtich is connected to an GbE uplink which is directly connected to a Cisco 3750G with unmetered connected (I am working in a hosting company myself). So all I am doing to test this is basically changing the virtual network card mapping from the virtual switch of the Sonic to the Clear OS router and vice versa and you immediately see the performance drop.
My own knowledge base made public: http://open902.com 
Comments
-
qwertyiop
Member Posts: 725 ■■■□□□□□□□
Ive played around with both ClearOS and Zentyal and I have to say stay away from both. -
Everyone
Member Posts: 1,661
Never did more than install it and poke around at it.
ClearOS is just a UI and suite of packages on top of CentOS, which is the open source version of Red Hat. So troubleshooting network performance should be just about the same as troubleshooting any other Red Hat based Linux distributions.
Quick Google search found similar issue to yours... Performance Problems - ClearFoundation
There's a reason I suggested pfsense for what you were trying to do first.